Here's an interesting one: Police in Arkansas have arrested a man for using information gleaned from the state's sex offender registry to get credit cards and tax refunds in the names of those offenders. He was busted at a routine traffic stop when the police officer noticed unusual files in the person's car.
ID thief trolled sex offender registry for targets
New privacy laws come into force in the US at midnight
January 1 is a convenient time to bring new laws into effect. It seems like only two years ago that PIPEDA came fully into force for those of us in Canada. (And almost two years since this blog came into being.) The Associated Press has a summary of new US state laws, some of which are in reaction to the high-profile privacy breaches of the last year. Check it out:
New Year Brings Array of New State Laws - Yahoo! News...This year, several states will take action to guard against the theft and misuse of personal information as more and more commerce moves to the Internet; several companies admitted in 2005 that hackers got into their supposedly secure databases. New Jersey and Virginia will bar making public a person's Social Security number, while Minnesota will require businesses that hold such information to quickly notify clients if there is a breach of security.
Tune in next week ...
Thanks to the series of articles in Canwest newspapers on privacy and surveillance that ran between Christmas and New Year's, I've been asked to be on a couple of radio shows at the beginning of next week. Tune in to Peter Anthony Holder's show on Monday night at 8:05pm (EST) on CJAD in Montreal (live radio feed here) or to the Bill Good show on Tuesday morning at 11:00am (PST) on CKNW in Vancouver (live radio feed here). I understand that there may be a call-in portion for both shows, so feel free to call with your privacy stories and questions. If they archive shows for posterity, I'll post a link.
Boxers have privacy rights, too.
The Globe and Mail is carrying a report that a boxer's medical information was released without his permission, perhaps having a significant impact upon his career. It is alleged that a clinic released neurological and MRI test results that showed cranial bleeding.
The Globe and Mail: Joe Mesi sues, alleging breach of privacy:"Buffalo - Boxer Joe Mesi is suing a medical clinic and the New York State Athletic Commission, alleging they improperly distributed medical records that indicated he suffered multiple brain bleeds in his last fight...."
David Canton's PIPEDA predictions for 2006
David Canton, in his regular London Free Press Column, is making a few predictions for 2006. He leads off his column with predictions about privacy in Canada:
London Free Press - Business - Expect PIPEDA debatesThe Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) is slated for review in 2006. Expect to debate to rage on controversial issues such as whether individuals should be notified if their personal information is compromised.
Another issue is processing data outside Canada, common in a connected world. It raises issues regarding the ability of foreign governments to view our personal information -- without our knowledge, without judicial oversight, and despite contractual arrangements to the contrary.
A privacy issue that may come before the privacy commissioner is the printing of full credit or debit card numbers on receipts. This matter has not been the focus of a complaint to the privacy commissioner's office.
Many privacy commentators, myself included, believe that putting full credit or debit card numbers on either the customer's or the company's copy of a receipt is a violation of PIPEDA. The printing of those numbers serves no purpose and increases the risks of fraud.
Single Government ID Moves Closer to Reality
Further to my earlier posting on the new US Government identity verification project (PIPEDA and Canadian Privacy Law: US Government developing standard for positive identification), the Washington Post is carrying an article that comments, among other things, on privacy objections to the new standard:
Single Government ID Moves Closer to Reality:"....Some federal employees have concerns about the new cards.
Colleen M. Kelley, president of the National Treasury Employees Union, which represents more than 150,000 federal workers in 30 agencies, said the proposed standard would permit agencies to print employees' pay grade and rank on the new cards, which many workers would consider an invasion of privacy.
'For example, an agency might seize upon this technology as a means to track employees as they move throughout a building,' Kelley said in written comments to NIST last week. 'That is troubling, standing alone. It would be particularly objectionable if the agency tried to track visits to particular sites such as the union office, Employee Assistance Program offices and the inspector general's office.'
NIST has gathered comments on the draft standard from more than 500 entities and individuals but has not made them public.... "
I wonder how long it will take before this makes its way into IDs for civilians, such as passports and drivers' licences.
Tools to Make Your Hard Drive Forget Its Past
The New York Times circuits section is running an article entitled Tools to Make Your Hard Drive Forget Its Past. The title is a bit misleading, since it only lists the tools to need to reformat your drive to start from scratch with a fresh installation of your software.
If you really want to erase your hard drive to preserve the confidentiality of your information before you sell or ditch your PC, you need a toolkit that truly destroys the data that is written on the magentic media. A number of products are available on the market that at least purport to meet rigorous standards, such as those set by the US Department of Defence (See Google Search: DoD 5220.22-M). The Canadian RCMP recommends, in their Hard Drive Secure Information Removal and Destruction Guidelines, that hard drives containing Secret or Top Secret data be disintegrated into itty bitty pieces (smaller than 1/4 of an inch).
2005 worst year for breaches of computer security
USA Today is reporting that 2005 has been the worst year yet for computer security and security of personal information. Maybe... Equally likely: it was the year that we heard about breaches that otherwise would have been swept under the carpet. The only difference is the range of laws following in California's footsteps. See: 2005 worst year for breaches of computer security - Yahoo! News.
Automated fare system upsets some in Boston
The ACLU is getting a bit hot and bothered about a new fare system about to be implemented by the Boston area transportation authority. Tokens are being phased out and replaced by debit-type fare cards. Riders can purchase a pre-loaded fare card that is discarded when used up, but others can opt for a reloadable pass that is connected to their bank account. The system will track where and when the cards are used (a sensible auditing function). The ACLU is concerned that riders who opt for this choice will be sacrificing privacy for convenience since their records will be available if the transit authority is served with a subpoena or a search warrant. It seems a little overblown, as long as consumers know they have the choice of an anonymous option and make the decision knowingly. See: T defends automated fare system against privacy concerns - The Boston Globe.
Files on welfare-to-work clients found in dumpster
After someone found files containing personal information on welfare-to-work clients (including names, addresses, SSNs) in a dumpster, the San Joaquin County Office of Education in California is investigating. Apparently they were left in a car sold by a former department employee who didn't care enough to collect them when informed by the buyer that a box of stuff was left in the car. See: County probes confidential files in trash.
Invasive technology makes schools more like "correctional facilities"
The third article in the series of privacy articles by CanWest Global is now online from the Ottawa Citizen's site: Security-riddled schools more like 'correctional facilities':
Instead of making students feel safer, an education professor argues extreme surveillance makes them feel like criminals, writes Sarah Schmidt.
Edmonton pawnshop owner takes a stand over electronic reporting of personal information of customers to police
As of January 1, 2006, pawnshop operators in the City of Edmonton will be required by a city bylaw to enter information about customers into a database that will be electronically transmitted to the police. He has always collected this sort of information, as required by law, but Kelly Buryuniuk is not at all happy with having to send it to the cops, particularly via a private contractor. He is concerned about the security of that data, he says. The pawnshop operator says he will defy the bylaw, even if it gets his license suspended. The Information and Privacy Comissioner of Alberta is reviewing the system. See: edmontonsun.com - Edmonton News - Standoff brewing.
Banks up customer surveillance
Stuart Laidlaw has a very interesting article on customer surveillance at Canadian banks and the impact of the USA Patriot Act on their vigilance: TheStar.com - Banks up customer surveillance.
Privacy law is making hospitals lose patients and patient attitudes to privacy
icWales has an article ("Privacy law is making hospitals lose patients") on the the new practice of removing--in the name of privacy--patients' nameplates from above their beds and whiteboards from nursing stations. This has led to substandard care and literally losing patients, at least in Wales. The article cites a survey published in the British Medical Journal that examined the attitudes of patients to having their names made known in this way. (Ravindra Gudena, Stanley Luwemba, Amy Williams, and Lloyd R Jenkinson,
Data protection gone too far: questionnaire survey of patients' and visitors' views about having their names displayed in hospital,
BMJ, Dec 2004; 329: 1491.)
Based on a very simple questionnaire, most did not find the practice of posting patients names was invasive of privacy and most felt that patient names should appear over their beds:
Responses of 243 patients and 215 visitors to questionnaires about patients in hospital having their names displayed. Values are numbers; percentages (95% confidence intervals)
Patients
Visitors
Totals
Have you seen the name board or not?Yes 173; 71 (65 to 77) 157; 73 (67 to 79) 330; 72 (68 to 77) No 70; 29 (23 to 35) 58; 27 (21 to 33) 128; 28 (24 to 32)
Where should the name board be located?In the open 182; 75 (70 to 80) 160; 74 (69 to 80) 342; 75 (70 to 79) Hidden 4; 2 (3 to 7) 12; 6 (0 to 12) 16; 3 (2 to 5) No preference 57; 23 (19 to 28) 43; 20 (14 to 26) 100; 22 (18 to 26)
Do you mind having your name displayed on the name board (or, does this infringe on patients' privacy?)Yes 10; 4 (2 to 7) 21; 10 (2 to 5) 31; 7 (4 to 9) No 233; 96 (93 to 98) 194; 90 (84 to 94) 427; 93 (91 to 96)
Should patients' names be displayed above their beds?Yes 236; 97 (95 to 99) 201; 93 (90 to 97) 437; 95 (94 to 97) No 7; 3 (5 to 8) 14; 7 (3 to 10) 21; 5 (3 to 7)
This raises a number of questions about the wisdom of certain privacy laws and practices in the clinical environment. I wonder whether one can imply consent to having one's name posted over their bed if a good survey strongly suggests that the majority of patients don't object and, in fact, think that posting their names is a good idea. If you couple this with an opportunity to "opt out" on the admitting form, you should be able to satisfy most of the people most of the time.
Privacy and location-capable cell phones
The author of Sent.Org, aka [evL] blog, has an interesting and long posting that starts with a discussion of the privacy issues inherent in GPS capable cell phones, which leads into a broader discussion of privacy issues and routine law enforcement access to personal information. Rather than summarize it, I suggest taking a look at the blog posting itself:
:: [ evL ] Calling? :: sent.org :: [ evL ] blog :: sent :: [ evL ]:"IF YOU PURCHASED A NEW CELLPHONE over the past 18 months or so, odds are that one of the features listed in small print on the side of the box was "E911 capable." Or, as in the case of my latest Motorola, "Location technology for piece [sic] of mind." Perhaps you asked the salesman to explain the feature, and he replied that it means that cops can home in on your phone in case of an emergency, a potentially important perk should you ever find your hand pinned beneath an immovable boulder in rural Utah, as Aron Ralston did recently. Assuming he could have gotten a signal, an E911-capable phone might have saved the young backpacker the pain of having to amputate his own arm.
What your salesman probably failed to tell you--and may not even realize--is that an E911-capable phone can give your wireless carrier continual updates on your location. The phone is embedded with a Global Positioning System chip, which can calculate your coordinates to within a few yards by receiving signals from satellites. GPS technology gave U.S. military commanders a vital edge during Gulf War II, and sailors and pilots depend on it as well. In the E911-capable phone, the GPS chip does not wait until it senses danger, springing to life when catastrophe strikes; it's switched on whenever your handset is powered up and is always ready to transmit your location data back to a wireless carrier's computers. Verizon or T-Mobile can figure out which manicurist you visit just as easily as they can pinpoint a stranded motorist on Highway 59.
So what's preventing them from doing so, at the behest of either direct marketers or, perhaps more chillingly, the police? Not the law, which is essentially mum on the subject of location-data privacy... "
They're watching and know who you are
Part two of the weeklong series of articles on privacy issues by Canwest reporter Richard Foot has been published in the Ottawa Citizen, Montreal Gazette, Vancouver Sun, etc. This part is on surveillance and the possibility of pervasive surveillance being coupled with facial recognition software.
They're watching you, and they know who you are (Ottawa Citizen):"Biometric face recognition is about to change the way governments do business, and could remove our last shreds of anonymity, writes Richard Foot.
Richard Foot
The Ottawa CitizenDecember 28, 2004
In London, Ont., 16 video cameras mounted on traffic poles keep a 24-hour watch on downtown streets for the city's police. In New York City, more than 2,400 outdoor video cameras -- many operated by private companies -- gaze out over the streets of Manhattan alone.
'No matter what, walking through the world these days, you're going to end up on video camera,' says David Fraser, a Halifax privacy lawyer.
Public surveillance isn't a new phenomenon, but despite its creeping presence, Canadians have maintained a measure of anonymity when we venture outside our homes. Video cameras might be watching us in public places, but unless we're famous or infamous, they usually can't identify who we are.
Until now...."
Incident: Marriott missing backup tapes with records of 206,000
Marriot International's timeshare division has started to notify customers, employees and credit card companies that backup tapes with records (including SSNs) of two hundred six thousand individuals is missing. There is no info on whether the data has been used for nefarious purposes and Marriott cannot determine whether it is just missing or stolen. See: Marriott Discloses Missing Data Files.
Privacy concerns about online library service: patron records available for others to see
Mary Minnow, at the Library Law Blog has recently posted about a service called Library Elf. This service plugs into your local library's computer system so you can see what books you have checked out, when they are due back and what is the status of any holds you have. In using the system, Mary has found that you can see other patrons' records. She isn't happy about that.
See: LibraryLaw Blog: "This card is viewed by other accounts" - an update on the Library Elf and your privacy and LibraryLaw Blog: Breaking Discovery - Library Elf blasts a giant hole through privacy - and why I terminated my account.
Grocery Store Loyalty Card Use is Strong Despite Privacy Concerns
A recent survey has confirmed what I've thought for some time: consumers will trade away their privacy at the drop of a hat. The study from Boston University suveyed a range of US consumers on their use and attitude to loyalty cards. Consumers will consistently trade their anonymity (and thus privacy) in exchange for discounts and other perceived benefits. This is even the case for those who are concerned about privacy (16% of those surveyed think about the personal information they are giving away each time they use their cards).
I'll try to find more information on the study, particularly the questions asked as part of the survey. I'm particularly curious if consumers selectively use their cards out of concern for the information that would be included in their profiles (for example, privacy-conscious consumers may not use their cards when they purchase items that may disclose too much personal information) and whether they really think about all the uses to which the information may be put.
The press release is reproduced in full below:
PRESS RELEASE: Grocery Store Loyalty Card Use is Strong Despite Privacy Concerns:"New research from Boston University finds that 86% of adults carry a grocery store loyalty card and use it, even though cards give stores the right to track consumer purchases.
Boston, MA (PRWEB) December 28, 2004 -- Grocery story loyalty cards are more widespread than the Internet or the home computer: 86% of adults have at least one, most have more than one. Yet nearly half of the people who carry them didn’t know about the sophisticated web of tracking and marketing they were getting stuck in when they signed up. Is this a privacy bomb waiting to go off? No, according to results of a Fall 2004 study by a student research team at Boston University’s College of Communication. In an online survey of 515 adult supermarket shoppers the students found that even though privacy concerns are high, most cardholders agree that the benefits of using a loyalty card outweigh any infringement on personal privacy.
Grocery store loyalty cards are the credit card or keychain-sized cards with a barcode or magnetic stripe offered by most large supermarket chains. Chances are good you have at least one in your wallet or purse. When scanned at the cash register, the card unlocks special discounts offered to “loyal” members. In return for the savings, cardholders agree to allow the grocery store to track their purchases each time they shop. Grocery stores use this information to decide which products to carry, what prices to charge, and in some cases, to target consumers with specific coupons and promotions on behalf of grocery manufacturers.
Actual grocery store uses vary by store – some find the data analysis so time consuming they have chosen to abandon the cards altogether as PW Supermarkets, a small chain in Northern California, recently did. Still others have sophisticated systems for matching publicly available information about consumer households with the data collected at the cash register, a practice that infuriates privacy advocacy groups.
Does this tracking influence the consumer’s choice to use a discount card? A clear majority – 76% – of cardholders report that they use their grocery store loyalty card nearly every time they shop despite the fact that 52% also are concerned about how much of their personal information is collected by companies generally. Why do it, then? Sixty-nine percent of consumers report that the card benefits them in the form of lower prices and access to special promotions. And while seven in ten shoppers now know that grocery stores keep track of what they spend, only 16% think about this fact each time they use it.
“The fact that consumers – even those generally concerned about privacy – are willing to use these cards is testament to the fact that personal information is a commodity people are willing to trade with the right company for the right price,” explains Professor James McQuivey, who supervised the research project. No doubt this will only embolden supermarkets as they try to squeeze ever more dollars from a thin-margin retailing environment. What’s next? McQuivey offers, “Expect radio frequency identification embedded in the loyalty card of the future, an electronic tag that will identify you when you walk through the door, when you’re standing in front of the Pampers, and when you arrive at checkout. All with your permission, of course, and in exchange for a benefit grocery stores have yet to identify.”
About the survey
An online survey of 515 people 18 years of age and older was conducted during the last week of October 2004. As such it can only represent the two-thirds of households with Internet access. Sample was randomly drawn from a representative subgroup of participants in Survey Sampling International’s US online panel. The margin of error for a randomly drawn sample this size is +/-5%.
About the College of Communication at Boston University
The College of Communication at Boston University is home to the Communication Research Center where professors train undergraduate and graduate students in the science of consumer research and analysis. This project was designed by students under the supervision of Professor James McQuivey.
Contact Information:
James McQuivey
Assistant Professor
College of Communication
Boston University
640 Commonwealth Ave
Boston, MA 02215
617.803.6209 p
617.507.7892 f"
Your daily digital data droppings
Canwest Global is doing a series of feature-length articles on privacy between Christmas and New Year. For the first one, I was "shadowed" by a reporter to look at the sorts of data that we leave in our wake as we go throughout our daily lives.
Our every move is tracked and recorded:
"Short of becoming a hermit, there's little Canadians can do to avoid the pervasive climate of surveillance that surrounds them, says Richard Foot. However, there is protection in knowing what information is sought, how it is collected, and why.
The Ottawa Citizen
Monday, December 27, 2004David Fraser walks out his front door on a midwinter morning bound for work. His movements and activities are under surveillance, tracked by networks of people and distant computers in his own city and around the planet.
Mr. Fraser isn't a wanted man, nor is he a foreign spy. He's an ordinary Canadian inhabiting a world so wired by ubiquitous technology that almost everything he does is monitored and measured in breathtaking detail.
Mr. Fraser, a Halifax privacy lawyer, isn't concerned about the surveillance itself. What worries him is that most Canadians simply don't know their lives are so closely watched by the silent eyes of business and government. Like federal privacy commissioner Jennifer Stoddart, he calls public ignorance about the vast, daily exchange of personal information the greatest threat to privacy in Canada today.
'The critical thing is that people must be aware of it,' Mr. Fraser says. 'Yet most people simply don't understand much private information they leave behind them each day, during their ordinary routines.'...
The Series
Tomorrow: Biometric wizardry poised to remove last shreds of anonymity.
Wednesday: School security: When safety concerns override privacy rights.
Thursday: Your health records in cyberspace.
Friday: Lives and habits of Canadian consumers up for grabs."
I'll post links to the stories as the appear online.
